- Home
- Seek Advice
- Differences Between Coaching And Mentoring
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN COACHING AND MENTORING EXPLAINED
The differences between coaching and mentoring are important to understand. Coaching and mentoring are two distinct approaches to personal and professional development that have been gaining popularity in recent years. While they share some similarities, they are fundamentally different and it is vital to comprehend the differences between them in order to choose the right approach for your needs.
FTC Disclosure: This site contains affiliate links from which I may receive a small commission for purchases made through the links. Read more in the footer.
The intent of this article is to explore what coaching and mentoring are, how they differ, and their respective advantages and disadvantages. We hope to provide sufficient information to allow you to make the right decisions in your desire to reach a new level in your career.
Many of us face a decision sometime in our career as to what the next step should be. There may be specific areas in your personal development that you want to address. You may desire to reach specific goals in your current organization or industry.
Alternatively, you may have had enough of your existing career field and desperately need to shift careers altogether. You want guidance and insight as to what to expect and prepare for.
Let’s address the important differences between coaching and mentoring and how they may help you reach your career goals.
THE DEFINITION OF COACHING AND MENTORING
The best way to begin to understand both the direct and subtle differences is to provide definitions.
Coaching: “Partnering with clients in a thought-provoking and creative process that inspires them to maximize their personal growth and professional potential.”
~ The International Coaching Federation
Coaching can be thought of as a professional relationship between a coach and a client, in which the coach helps the client to achieve their goals and improve their performance. Coaching is goal-oriented, with a focus on immediate issues and specific outcomes. The coach and the client work together to identify areas for improvement and help them to develop and implement strategies to achieve their goals which may include their personal life. Coaching is typically time-limited and can be conducted one-on-one or in a group setting.
One of the key characteristics of coaching is that the coach is an outside expert who provides guidance and support. The coach is not a subject matter expert in the client's field. Instead, they focus on helping the client to identify and overcome any obstacles or challenges they may face. The coaching process usually involves setting clear goals, creating an action plan, and regularly reviewing progress towards those goals. Coaching is often used in a business or professional context to help individuals improve their interpersonal skills and performance.
COACHING
A good coach is one who can help evaluate your own experience and leadership skills, focus on training, and develop the mindset to reach your goal. An evaluation is key to help you understand yourself and how it reflects in your desires. It is said to be non-directive. That is, the coaching program is set up with the coach more likely asking questions and giving the person being coached a chance to reflect and provide their responses.
Based on this discussion, the person may have a better view of steps they should take to advance in the direction they desire.
WHEN TO USE A COACH
The best time to use an effective coach is when you want assistance to:
- Provide guidance to address your specific personal development or career development.
- Prioritize areas for improvement.
- Separate the steps required for you to meet your career goals by breaking them down in phases.
- Work with you to develop your full potential.
- Develop different ways to improve specific skills.
- Ensure the coaching relationship maintains its direction to reach the desired outcomes.
AVAILABLE COACHING SERVICES
Several organizations are available to help you numerous ways as career coaches, life coaches, or many other categories. Here are several that have made a name for themselves with their coaching program.
CAREERFITTER
You know you want out, but not sure where to go next? Where will you feel comfortable in that role?
Discover which careers fit your personality strengths at work. Discover which jobs fit you best.
Take a FREE career assessment test.
Steps:
- Answer 60 questions about you. There are no wrong answers.
- View your full work personality report online. Discover your work personality strengths and career list.
- Your careers are linked to videos, career research, and job openings near you. Discover how much money you can earn, what to expect, tips to get started, and who is hiring near you.
See if this career assessment test gives you the direction you need to take the next step toward your new career.
JOBSTARS USA
They provide resume preparation help through resume writing, LinkedIn optimization, and distributing your resume to recruiters.
Jobstars has packages available to help in several areas:
>Making a Career Change
>Mock Interview
>A La Carte Services for entry level through executive level professionals. Three different levels of service are available.
To dig deeper into different options available read our page on finding a career coach and career change resume writing services.
MENTORING
Mentoring: “The practice of assigning a junior member of staff to the care of a more experienced person who assists him in his career.”
~ Dictionary.com
(It is common for mentors outside of the organization to provide such guidance to a mentee to better navigate their desire path.)
Mentoring, on the other hand, is a relationship between an experienced mentor and a less experienced mentee. The mentor is a subject matter expert in the mentee's field and provides guidance and support as the mentee navigates their career.
Unlike coaching, mentoring usually has a longer-term focus. A great mentor often plays a more significant role in the mentee's professional development. The mentor can also be utilized by the mentee to learn more about a particular career field and provide guidance and insight to the mentee. Getting answers to the questions a mentee has can have a significant impact on their decisions for career advancement. Mentoring relationships can be established through formal programs, but are often informal, evolving out of personal or professional connections.
A more detailed discussion will help to capture each of the differences between coaching and mentoring.
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN COACHING AND MENTORING
The key differences between coaching and mentoring are the focus and goals of the relationship. While coaching focuses on specific goals and objectives, mentoring is more focused on professional growth and steps that need to be taken to reach the goals. The mentor acts as a role model and provides guidance and support as the mentee navigates their career. The mentor may also offer advice on specific issues and provide opportunities for the mentee to learn and grow in their employee development.
The nature of the client relationship with the coach is different than the mentee relationship with the mentor. Coaching is a professional relationship that is focused on achieving specific goals that do not necessarily relate to career objectives. However, mentoring is a more personal relationship that is focused on the professional development and career objectives. In a coaching relationship, the coach is a facilitator who helps the client to achieve their goals, while in a mentoring program or mentoring relationship, the mentor is a guide who provides support and advice.
Finally, the role of a coach and the role of a mentor is different. The coach is focused on helping the client to achieve specific goals, while the mentor provides guidance and support to achieve the goals of the mentee work and for the mentee's overall career development. The coach is a facilitator who helps the client to identify and overcome obstacles, while the mentor is a role model who provides guidance and advice.
Discover more information on Mentoring:
ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF COACHING AND MENTORING
While both coaching and mentoring have advantages and disadvantages, it is important to choose the right approach for your specific needs. Coaching can be a great option if you are looking to achieve specific goals and improve your performance in a particular area. It is also a good choice if you are looking for a structured and time-limited approach to personal and professional development.
On the other hand, mentoring is a better option if you are looking for specific guidance and support in your career. A good mentor can provide you with a deeper understanding of your field and offer insight into the challenges and opportunities that you may face. Mentoring can also provide you with a sounding board for your ideas and a source of motivation and inspiration. However, mentoring can also be less structured than coaching and may require more effort and commitment from both the mentor and mentee
ADVANTAGES OF COACHING AND MENTORING
In terms of advantages, coaching can help you to achieve specific goals and improve your performance in a particular area. It can also help you to develop new skills and knowledge, and to overcome obstacles and challenges. Coaching can also provide you with a structured approach to personal and professional development and can help you to stay focused and motivated.
The advantages of mentoring include long-term guidance and support in your career, a deeper understanding of your field, and exposure to new ideas and opportunities. Mentoring can also help you to develop your skills and knowledge, and to build relationships with experienced professionals in your field. Additionally, mentoring can provide you with a sense of community and a sense of belonging in your field.
DISADVANTAGES OF COACHING AND MENTORING
There are also some disadvantages to both coaching and mentoring. Coaching can be expensive and may not be accessible to everyone. It can also be difficult to find a coach who is a good fit for your needs and goals. Additionally, coaching may not be suitable for everyone and may not address deeper, long-term issues.
A potential disadvantage of mentoring is the time and effort spent to identify and locate an individual that possesses the skills and experience in the specific area in which a mentee has an interest. Online mentoring services can help an individual locate mentors in the career categories they are interested in such as the list provided in Career Redo. Locating business mentors that are willing and anxious to provide insight and guidance can be challenging. However, you can find our list of willing mentors right here. Additionally, mentoring relationships can be more informal and less structured than coaching relationships
CONCLUSION OF DIFFERENCES BETWEEN COACHING AND MENTORING
It is important to understand the differences between coaching and mentoring and to choose the right approach for your needs. Both coaching and mentoring can provide you with valuable opportunities for personal and professional development, but each has its own advantages and disadvantages. Whether you choose coaching or mentoring, it is important to have a clear understanding of your goals and to work with a trusted and experienced professional who can help you to achieve those goals.
Should you have any questions on our discussion, please let me know.
Our Free Guide Gives You An Easy Way To Find Your Mentor And Begin Your Career Change
Don D'Armond is the creator of Career Redo.
His goal is to connect his visitors who want to learn more about their desired new career fields with experienced individuals (Mentors) to transfer their insight and knowledge.
your mentor + quality insight = Dream career
CAREERREDOTM.com by blue impala, l.l.c. | All Rights Reserved.
Copyright © 2017 –